In our September 2018 bulletin we reported on the important Queensland Supreme Court case of Narumon which held that:

  • provided the trust deed does not preclude it, an attorney under an enduring power of attorney is able to affirm an existing binding death benefit nomination (BDBN) made by a fund member;
  • however, the ability for an attorney to sign a new BDBN is likely to require a conflict transaction authorisation provision in the EPOA to be effective.

In saying this, the Court held that there was nothing in the SIS Act which precluded an attorney from signing a BDBN on behalf of a member and went on to say that a BDBN was not a testamentary act.

Further confusion

Unfortunately though Narumon was considered recently by the West Australian Estate Administrative Tribunal. The Tribunal held that:

The making of a BDBN where the represented person has a beneficial interest in the fund the subject of the BDBN is a testamentary act or disposition“.

As a consequence of this, the West Australian Tribunal has said that an attorney is unable to make a BDBN.

Admittedly the West Australian Tribunal is a lower Court than the Queensland Supreme Court and much of the argument in the case concerned relevant provisions of the West Australian Guardianship & Administration Act.

Nevertheless, it does mean there is some degree of uncertainty as to whether an attorney can or cannot sign a BDBN. It follows that, in the absence of any further higher Court authority, the decision of the Queensland Supreme Court in Narumon is to be preferred.  Certainly carefully-drawn provisions in an enduring power of attorney document specifying appropriate powers (including a conflict authorisation if necessary) would be desirable.

Latest News

April 18, 2024

A housing trust’s modernisation requires Court approval

Background The Baxter Homes Trust (Trust), was a charitable trust established in Victoria by a deed executed in 1960. Its purpose was to provide aged inhabitants of Geelong Victoria or its neighbourhood with housing as administered by The Geelong and Western District Ladies Benevolent Association’ incorporated under the Hospitals and Charities Act 1890. The Trust A housing trust’s modernisation requires Court approval

Read Article

April 18, 2024

Draft Regulations for NPO Self-Review Assessment Return Released

We have previously written in bulletins about the forthcoming self-assessment tax review for non-profit profit organisations which have an Australian Business Number (ABN) but are not registered as charities with the ACNC – Be alert to being alarmed on viewing your club or society annual report this year and self-assessment by tax-exempt. The background is Draft Regulations for NPO Self-Review Assessment Return Released

Read Article

March 13, 2024

Last of the loopholes? Let’s hope so!

Background All Australian employers will be acutely aware that the Federal government has, since the last election, embarked on a fairly aggressive program of targeted changes to the nation’s industrial relations laws. So far, we’ve had changes aimed at supporting Australia’s jobs and economic recovery[1], gained more respect at work[2], we’ve secured our jobs and Last of the loopholes? Let’s hope so!

Read Article